Five Star remains undervalued, Senior Star says
Although Five Star Quality Care's June 29 sale of seven of its 33 senior living communities to Senior Housing Properties Trust is “encouraging,” the company remains undervalued, two Five Star shareholders said Monday.
Tulsa, OK-based Senior Star Management Co. co-founders William F. Thomas and Robert D. Thomas, in a letter to fellow shareholders filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, reasserted their opinion that the company's board and management need to shift strategies in order for share price to reflect what they believe is the company's intrinsic value. The Thomases own approximately 3.4 million Five Star shares, or 6.8% of outstanding shares.
To improve its market value and increase long-term cash flow, the Thomases wrote, the Newton, MA-based Five Star should monetize its owned assets, de-leverage off-balance sheet lease obligations and reinvest “significantly” in existing leased communities.
The Thomases said they issued the letter in response to Five Star's recent sale of seven communities to Senior Housing Properties Trust for $112.4 million. The trust subsequently leased the properties back to Five Star, according to a July 1 filing with the SEC. Under terms of the lease, Five Star will pay Senior Housing Properties Trust annual rent of approximately $8.4 million, plus, beginning in 2018, percentage rent equal to 4% of the amount by which gross revenues of each community exceed the previous year's gross revenues.
“While the recent efforts of Five Star's management to monetize the company's balance sheet are encouraging, we are concerned by the additional leverage and cash flow burden placed on the company,” William Thomas wrote. “We continue to believe that Five Star is significantly undervalued with the potential to be a best-in-class operator. However, until leadership can consistently demonstrate independence from other affiliated entities, achieving that potential will be a long and challenging road.”
Senior Star offers independent living, assisted living, memory care, nursing care and home health services through its 2,200 units in 14 communities located in six states.