Possible catch-22 identified in right-to-die states

Share this content:

More states are passing right-to-die laws laden with strict eligibility rules that could cause complications for seniors and their caregivers.

They typically include a diagnosis of less than six months to live, an ability to self-administer a lethal prescription and mental competency at the time when the drug is requested. The last two requirements can essentially rule out dementia and stroke victims, according to a Mercury News story.

Yet as people live longer, strokes and Alzheimer's disease are becoming more common. Stroke was the fifth-leading cause of death in the United States in 2013, whereas Alzheimer's came in sixth. Although stroke recovery can be possible, Alzheimer's does not have a cure.

The Mercury News quoted Donna Cohen, Ph.D., a psychologist at the University of South Florida in Tampa, who acknowledged that the question of how to apply right-to-die laws to someone with dementia is a sticky one. Even if a person were to feel strongly about not wanting to live with advanced dementia, the person's feelings might change as the disease progresses, she noted.

In Focus

June 20

107 years young

Chambersburg, PA 

Irene Rebok, a resident of Magnolias of Chambersburg, will celebrate her 107th birthday with a visit from a state representative and a "card shower."